Archive

Posts Tagged ‘Mayor Dennis Phillips’

Study states that the City of Kingsport should not be aligned with State Theater project

January 11th, 2010 No comments

image

I have previously written concerning the proposal that the City of Kingsport buy the old State Theater  See post Kingsport Developer gets in over his head, thinks old theater may be haunted and wants city to bail him out.

Now the completed study by the Cinema Preservation Group is out and can be read in its entirety in the link below.  Read and form your own conclusions.

Kingsport Economic Development Board recently voted to spend nearly $10,000 to fund a study to determine the economic impact of a restored theater in downtown Kingsport. The Cinema Preservation Group is now conducting the work.

KEDB Chairman Bob Feathers said he contacted Beatty about the possibility of the city purchasing or investing in the theater after learning that Beatty was considering nonprofit status for the facility.

Feathers said he believes some type of investment can occur to complete the theater project — regardless of what the economic development study shows.

Read more via City may consider buying State Theater building – Kingsport Times-News Online.

In the recent Kingsport Times-News article below, Mayor Dennis Phillips denies that the city plans to buy the State Theatre outright.  I wonder what Mayor Phillips has in mind when he stated “without an enormous expense to the taxpayers”?

Mayor Dennis Phillips said he hopes the study will encourage some individual or organization to invest in the State Theater, complete the renovations, and begin operating it for the benefit of the downtown district.

“I think if we can accomplish this without an enormous expense to the taxpayers, it certainly would be a service that is sorely needed,” Phillips said.

Asked about the Strand Theater, another Broad Street historic facility that has recently been used as a venue for live music and old movies, Phillips said the Cinema Preservation Group study could also be used by the Strand owners if they would want to market the facility one day. The Strand Theatre is owned by Restoration Church.

“I don’t know if the Strand Theater is available today. The Strand Theatre is a church,” he said.

But if the Strand were put on the market, “this report would apply … then it becomes a matter of economics of which one could be done at the least cost,” Phillips said.

He denied that the city plans to buy the State Theatre outright.

via Study envisions new future for State Theatre – Kingsport Times-News Online.

The report from the Cinema Preservation Group states that there are major problems when a non-profit theater is aligned too closely with city hall.  Below are two paragraphs from the study.  I would encourage you to read the entire report.

Non-profit theatres aligned too closely with city hall often fall prey to two particular problems. The first occurs when the theatre building comes to be perceived as a public facility. Various public entities feel that they should be allowed to use the facility for significantly discounted rates, or even for free. Though currently not an issue in the case of the State, this type of agreement is often adopted in order to ensure initial approval for restoration by the council and guarantee the allocation of funds for building renovations and/or other expenses. Severely discounted rates take revenue away from the theatre and occupy blocks of time that could be filled by other groups who would pay to use the building. The second problem arises when city residents perceive the theatre to be a municipal building. When this happens, it becomes extremely difficult to raise money from the community. Fundraising efforts are either simply ignored or opposed outright, and individual donors become wary of contributing to an entity they feel could and should be largely financed by tax dollars.

…….Though ticket and concession sales are the primary sources of revenue for a theatre, there are other means of earning revenue that must be explored. The vast majority of live theatres in America today will never be self-supporting, they can simply never make enough money on ticket sales and concessions to cover expenses. Even in good economic times many theatres are fortunate to earn 50% of their revenue from events. Two strategies for overcoming this revenue shortfall are fundraising and rental.

Read more via The Cinema Preservation Group Study

The survey that was used in the study is questionable because the Cinema Preservation Group chose to use the blog that is maintained by Kingsport’s Assistant Manager, Jeff Flemming.  The readership of Jeff Flemming’s blog in my opinion would show a bias for the city of Kingsport and would not reflect the majority views of the Kingsport citizens.  See Time Sensitive: How do you feel about State Theatre?  I am sure that the response would have been different if this blog posted the survey.

It is interesting that the Cinema Preservation Group is from Asheville, NC.  Prior to coming to Kingsport, Doug Beatty lived in the Asheville area.

Also, it is interesting that  Richard Rose, artistic director at the Barter Theatre in Abingdon, sent a letter of support for the State Theatre restoration to Kingsport City Manager, John Campbell.  Rose said he reviewed the Cinema Preservation study.  It is also interesting that Doug Beatty lives in the Abingdon, Virginia area

See also DKA to partner with Restoration Church on Strand Theater project,

Drama unfolds at DKA press conference on old Strand Theater

Kingsport to borrow money to replace a $200k roof and finance it for 20 years

October 21st, 2009 No comments

image Last night the Kingsport, Tennessee Board of Mayor and Alderman voted to borrow $41.1 million for various projects.  According to the Kingsport Times-News quote below, the total debt has doubled in the last five years.  I might add that this has occurred during Mayor Dennis Phillips terms as mayor and John Campbell as city manager.

With this bond issuance, Kingsport’s total debt has doubled in the past five years, from $110 million in fiscal year 2006 to $218 million in fiscal year 2010, according to city records. Kingsport’s general fund debt will increase from the current amount of $92.6 million to $103.4 million for fiscal year 2010, while total city debt will go from $173.5 million to slightly more than $218 million.

Read more via Kingsport BMA approves $41.1 M in bonds – Kingsport Times-News Online.

Things must really be in bad shape for the city because they are borrowing $200k to replace a roof on the Renaissance Center and financing it for 20 years.  Borrowing money to replace a roof should be a maintenance item that is planned for and funded from within a yearly budget.

It would not surprise me that Kingsport will be the subject of many discussions by other cities on Kingsport’s management practices or lack thereof. 

Mayor Phillips, when can we expect the property tax increase?

Below is the spending that was approved

image

Kingsport, Tennessee High Crime Rate

October 19th, 2009 No comments

image Below is data that was obtained form the website NeighborhoodScout which gives some interesting data concerning the high crime rate in Kingsport, Tennessee.  Kingsport is ranked as having a high crime rank by NeighborhoodScout and states that  Kingsport’s crime rate is higher than the average for the State of Tennessee and  United States.

Are our city officials more concerned about putting in a new swimming pool, expanding the convention center, building more hotels, annexing more property, getting more restaurants, etc. than reducing the high crime rate in Kingsport?

Kingsport, TN Elected Officials – Board of Mayor and Alderman

If you have a concern about the crime in the city of Kingsport, click on the city officials names above to send them an email.

NeighborhoodScout

With a crime rate of 89 per one thousand residents, Kingsport has one of the highest crime rates in America compared to all communities of all sizes – from the smallest towns to the very largest cities. One’s chance of becoming a victim of either violent or property crime here is one in 11. Within Tennessee, more than 90% of the communities have a lower crime rate than Kingsport.

Separately, it is always interesting and important to compare a city’s crime rate with those of similarly sized communities – a fair comparison as larger cities tend to have more crime. NeighborhoodScout has done just that. With a population of 44,560, Kingsport has a combined rate of violent and property crime that is very high compared to other places of similar population size. Regardless of whether Kingsport does well or poorly compared to all other cities and towns in the US of all sizes, compared to places with a similar population, it fares badly. Few other communities of this size have a crime rate as high as Kingsport.

The crime data that NeighborhoodScout used for this analysis are the seven offenses from the uniform crime reports, collected by the FBI from 17,000 local law enforcement agencies, and include both violent and property crimes, combined.

Now let us turn to take a look at how Kingsport does for violent crimes specifically, and then how it does for property crimes. This is important because the overall crime rate can be further illuminated by understanding if violent crime or property crimes (or both) are the major contributors to the general rate of crime in Kingsport.

For Kingsport, we found that the violent crime rate is one of the highest in the nation, across communities of all sizes (both large and small). Violent offenses tracked included forcible rape, murder and non-negligent manslaughter, armed robbery, and aggravated assault, including assault with a deadly weapon. According to NeighborhoodScout’s analysis of FBI reported crime data, your chance of becoming a victim of one of these crimes in Kingsport is one in 107.

In addition, NeighborhoodScout found that a lot of the crime that takes place in Kingsport is property crime. Property crimes that are tracked for this analysis are burglary, larceny over fifty dollars, motor vehicle theft, and arson. In Kingsport, your chance of becoming a victim of a property crime is one in 13, which is a rate of 80 per one thousand population.

Click here to see the data below as well as a map showing where the safest places are in Kingsport.  At the top of the page you can get data for a different city.

image

image

Shocking News About Sullivan County Aging Population

October 8th, 2009 No comments

I have done many posts concerning the median age and population in Sullivan County, Tennessee and  Sullivan County has one of the oldest populations in the state (click here to view the data).

The data below is from the state and I hope will help illustrate exactly what will happen if Sullivan County continues as it has in the past.

Below in the graph is a breakdown on the population for the different age groups in Sullivan County for the census year 2000 and projections for year 2025.  Sullivan County population in year 2000 was 153,048 and is projected to be 161,262 in year 2025.

Note that in the graph below that the 2025 population for all age groups are less for age groups that are under the 55 to 59 age group.  The year 2025 graph shows that the population numbers shows the population growing for for ages group 55 and up.  The largest single age group with the largest population is the age group 75 and up and the larger part of them are females.

Sulivan-County-2000-to-2025

Is Sullivan County equipped to handle the aging population?  There should great demand for those businesses offering services to the elderly.  But, if you are a pediatric physician, you might want to start your practice elsewhere because of the low birth rate in Sullivan County.

The table below gives the actual population numbers for the different age groups.  I have added the year 2010 which is not plotted in the above graph so you can see what is projected for 2010.  The data from the state is given as number of males and females for each age group and I have added the male and female population numbers together in the table below and the graph.

Population Projections for Sullivan County, TN



Year
Age Group200020102025
0 to 48,5428,5937,897
5 to 99,4119,0128,498
10 to 149,7098,6978,538
15 to 199,2048,3307,514
20 to 247,7788,6927,638
25 to 299,6259,7518,180
30 to 3410,4208,6699,154
35 to 3911,53410,0789,887
40 to 4411,87310,86410,597
45 to 4911,54311,6979,357
50 to 5411,24111,64410,368
55 to 599,77611,50111,410
60 to 648,06610,98111,817
65 to 696,9199,11211,197
70 to 746,3586,9819,705
75 and up11,04913,96019,506
Total 153,048158,560161,262

You can view the data for other Tennessee Counties which includes projections for every five years up to year 2025.  Click on the link below to go to the Tennessee webpage

Demographic Information on Age-Gender Composition

In addition to the population projections for each Tennessee city and county contained in the report above, you may access more detailed cohort-component data for a city or county below. (Please note that updated demographic projections will be forthcoming.)

Please either click a county on the Tennessee state map or click a county name in the alphabetical list below the map to access the cohort-component data. Note the Word of Caution following table listed below.

Click here to view state data for Tennessee Counties


I am one of the older population and am concerned about the future of Sullivan County.   No, you can’t move us out of the county, but you should be concerned about the future of the county when we have left this world.  There must be something in place to keep young people in Sullivan County.  A good start would be get companies that have good paying jobs to locate here.   If you too are concerned, talk to your elected officials.  You can email them at the following links.

email Kingsport BMA

email Candidates for Tennessee Governor

email Tennessee Legislators for area

email Sullivan County Commissioners

See list for

or

Comments are welcome.

Kingsport’s downtown turf battle

October 2nd, 2009 No comments

image There is a turf battle occurring between the DKA (Downtown Kingsport Association) and DBA (Downtown Business Alliance).  These two competing organizations are trying to get funding from the City of Kingsport.

It is documented that Mayor Dennis Phillips has in the past attempted to merge the DKA into the Kingsport Chamber of Commerce.

image image The Kingsport Times-News reports that Mayor Phillips stated that at the Oct. 6, 2009 BMA meeting they would vote on Vice Mayor Mallicote proposal to withhold funding to the DKA if the DKA did not change their board leadership guidelines.  To me, this sounds like blackmail and it also points out that Mayor Phillips and Vice Mayor political allies are in the DBA organization.

If the DKA has a problem with the current BMA decisions, they could band together and vote out the current BMA in the next election.

There has been much that has been written on this dispute in the last few years.  See the links below.

Drama unfolds at DKA press conference on old Strand Theater

Kingsport leaders seek resolution to DKA, DBA dispute

Merchants air concerns over concert stage, moving concert location

Concerts causing friction between downtown organizations

DKA, DBA at loggerheads over best way to promote downtown Kingsport

DKA leaders set for merger meeting with chamber

City may consider buying State Theater building

DKA to partner with Restoration Church on Strand Theater project

Kingsport Developer gets in over his head, thinks old theater may be haunted and wants city to bail him out

Comments are welcome.

Kingsport, TN continues to buy up property in a recession

September 25th, 2009 No comments

Since the City of Kingsport, Tennessee is buying up real estate, I have included a sample classified ad that could be used by the city.  You can see a list of properties that the city owns by clicking here.  Copy the following in bold, kingsport city of and paste into the Owner Name on the Real Estate Assessment Data form.

Hint:  If you are serious about selling property to the city, then it would be a good idea to become a political ally first with the City of Kingsport elected leaders.

Merriam-Websterally

Meaning: someone associated with another to give assistance or moral support <in trying to convince his parents to send him to soccer camp, Toby had a real ally in his coach>

Synonyms abettor (also abetter), backer, confederate, supporter, sympathizer

Related Words well-wisher; accessory, accomplice, collaborationist, collaborator; adjunct, assistant, coadjutor, helper; associate, cohort, colleague, fellow, partner; buddy, chum, companion, comrade, confidant, crony, familiar, friend, intimate, mate, pal

Will Buy Real Estate
We Buy Commercial and Residential Real Estate – Fast CASH!!!
Any Condition.
Will Pay More $$$$$$ than It Is Worth.
Have Taxpayer Money to Waste Invest.
Relocation $$$$$$$ is available.

Call Mayor Dennis Phillips
or
Vice Mayor Mallicote
City of Kingsport, Tennessee
(423) 229-9447

Famous Quotes from the Kingsport Board of Mayor and Aldermen

Mayor Dennis Phillips – ‘We need MeadowView to keep from reducing fire, police protection, and reducing trash pick-up to every two weeks.” October 21, 2008

Mayor Dennis Phillips –“We need to annex so we don’t have to raise taxes”  February 5, 2008

Alderman Munsey – “We need to do the MeadowView expansion to keep from raising taxes” September 15, 2008

Alderman Munsey – Debt is neither good or bad,”   June 3, 2008

Vice Mayor Mallicote – “I do not believe all of the doom and gloom about the economy”.  June 3, 2008

Mayor Dennis Phillips – “If the taxpayers wanted the city to cut the spending, then we could collect garbage every other week”  June 3, 2008

Mayor Dennis Phillips – “If there were no money to spend, then you would not need politicians”  October, 2007

Kingsport Developer gets in over his head, thinks old theater may be haunted and wants city to bail him out

September 24th, 2009 No comments

image A developer comes from another state and buys the old State Theater on Broad Street in Kingsport, Tennessee.  This developer (Douglas Beatty) starts work to renovate the State Theater building and finds that with the economy and his other investments that it might be better to sell his unfinished State Theater building to the City of Kingsport.

Doug Beatty, the developer has stated that he wants to get out what he has so far paid for the building and renovations which is about $450,000.  He further states that the entire cost to renovate the building would be about $900,000.

It appears that Doug Beatty is well connected with Mayor Phillips, Vice Mayor Mallicote, BMA members and the Kingsport Economic Development Board recently voted to spend nearly $10,000 to fund a study to determine the economic impact of a restored theater in downtown Kingsport.

The Kingsport Times-News reports that Bob Feathers with the Kingsport Economic Development Board believes some type of investment can occur to complete the theater project — regardless of what the economic development study shows.  I guess the question is, why is the city of Kingsport spending $10,000 for a study when they are going to do what they want to do to make this developer happy.

image Let the private sector take care of this. The city of Kingsport has no business bailing out someone who got in over his head.  I am sure that there are many folks in Kingsport would like for the city to bail them out of their current financial situation.

image During the renovation process, Doug Beatty became aware of apparently paranormal occurrences inside.  According to L.E.M.U.R Paranormal Investigation website, Doug Beatty met with L.E.M.U.R and permitted an investigation.

Kingsport Times-News

“I need to,” he said. “I want to at least get what I’ve got in it so I can satisfy the bank note.”

The theater is now appraised at $1.6 million by private professional appraisers, and at $1 million for county tax purposes.

Beatty said work is still progressing on the theater. But he doesn’t want to invest in any more big-ticket items such as $30,000 in sheet rock or new theater seats, until he’s in a better position or the city moves forward with an acquisition.

“I’ve got two restaurants that I really have to tend to and make sure that they’re able to pay their bills and stay open. That’s really distracting me financially and time-wise from the theater,” Beatty said.

“I really want to get it done, but I’m at a point right now, because the economy has taken so long to come back, that I’m not sure how much more I can plow ahead without putting myself at risk. I want to make sure that I’m acting responsibly and cautiously as it relates to all the development we’re doing downtown,” he said.

Feathers said he believes some type of investment can occur to complete the theater project — regardless of what the economic development study shows.

“I sincerely doubt it will be dropped altogether. But you never know,” Feathers said. “Economies could drive something different from our perspective and what we’re trying to do from an economic development perspective.

“But from a priority standpoint, this is a very important component to what we see as a good fit for the community.”

The owner of the State Theater is DB3 Development Company, LLC and is North Carolina company.  DB3 Development Company, LLC is listed as a FOREIGN company according to the Tennessee Secretary of State.  Below is from the State of Tennessee website

Name
I.D. Number
DB3 DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, LLC
0533682
Business Type*:LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
Profit/Nonprofit:FOR PROFIT
Status*:ACTIVE
Date of Formation/Qualification:11/07/2006
Domestic/Foreign:FOREIGN
Place of Incorporation/Organization:NC
Duration:PERPETUAL
FYC(Fiscal Year Closing) Month:DECEMBER
Principal Office:
Address Line 1:11346 TOOLE CREEK RD
Address Line 2:
City:ABINGDON
State:VA
Zip:242108626
Other than USA:
Registered Agent:
Name: DOUGLAS BEATTY
Address Line 1: 501B E. MAIN ST.
Address Line 2:
City: KINGSPORT
State: TN
Zip: 376600000

According to Sullivan County, DB3 Development Co LLC also owns property at 227-229-23 Sullivan St.  It appears that there is construction work occurring at this location and the 2008 Sullivan County property taxes are not paid.

Let your Kingsport Board of Mayor and Alderman know your concerns about bailing out one of their pals.  Keep in mind the money spent to buy the State Theater will be your tax dollars.

email Kingsport BMA

    Feel free to leave a comment.

Past and New Direction of the No WhiteWash! Blog

September 3rd, 2009 No comments

This blog was started in February 2007 with the title of “Kingsport, TN Government”.  The name was later changed to “No WhiteWash!”, a name less focused on one local government.  We are still focused on Kingsport, TN Government and have expanded into issues that affect Sullivan County, North East Tennessee area, and the State as they are in a lot of case interrelated.

The direction of this blog for the future will be for the average citizen and not the elites who choose to run things for their own self-interest.  There will be no favoritism toward a political party in this blog.  WARNING:  If you are a elected official or running for office and make statements that you can’t back up or not exactly telling the full story, then this blog will expose them.  If you are running for office or an elected official who wants to use this blog for political advantage, then I would suggest you go elsewhere to peddle your story.  This blog is for the people!!

This little blog now has readership that is around 1,000 visits per day and that number could be much higher because other blogs re-publish this blog posts to their blogs.  There have been over 1,700 posts written in this blog since inception and the posts are not forgotten as they slide down the page as newer post take their place on the first page.  The search traffic coming to this blog is very large because this blog posts are indexed on all of the major search engines (Google, Yahoo, Microsoft, etc).  All of the posts go into a RSS news feed where readers can read the posts without having to visit the blog.  The folks using the RSS feed amounts to many hundred per day.

Over the last few years I have seen more local people become more vocal about expressing their views concerning how the local governments operate.  They express their views in the comments areas in the local newspapers, blogs, social media sites (Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, etc)  There have been many local blogs that have been started in the North East Tennessee area in the last few years and I think we will see more of it.

Blogs do get a lot of readership.  The Tea Party protests got their start from blogs and with very little help from local media.

The Show blog is another local blog that has come online and also has it own local talk radio show on Monday and Thursday from 6-8pm on WMCH AM1260.  Local issues are discussed in this radio talk show and in many cases the posts from this blog are discussed and the radio talk show does allow callers to phone in and express their views. 

I have learned much about the City of Kingsport government on how they operate.  The research that I have done has me very concerned about how the “elites” control the city and do things that are in their self-interests.  I do have a concern about their lack to fully understand the problems the area has such as low median wages, declining population, high unemployment, lack of good paying jobs, and young adults leaving the area to find work, etc.

I also have a concern how the mayor selects political appointees to serve on different committees so he can be assured that he get what he wants.  The reporting in the Kingsport Times-News is almost always, in my view, protecting the city officials.  One has to understand that if they reported anything negative about the city, then it would reflect on the upper management at the Kingsport Times-News.  This is because there are many of the top management at the Times-News that are Mayor Dennis Phillips’ political appointees.

We could go on about how certain people decide who should run for political office and then campaign for them and put up the money for them to get elected.

We could talk about the Ridgefield County Club elites or look at the details of the spending of city money by the Kingsport Chamber of Commerce, but these could be posts for another day.

There have been many that have sent this blog information concerning the operation of our local governments and I want to say thank you.  Please continue reporting as you have in the past.

If you have anything to report concerning the below areas, feel free to use the email icon below to report it. The source of the information will be kept confidential.

  • City of Kingsport, TN
  • City of Bristol, TN
  • Sullivan County, TN
  • North East, TN
  • Tennessee Government

Issues such as wasteful spending, local elections, annexation, ethics, crime, conflicts of interest, backroom deals, open government, abuse of taxpayer money, etc., are examples to report, but not limited to those listed.

Tear down MeadowView Conference Center or give it away

August 19th, 2009 No comments

image MeadowView had its grand opening on August 18, 2009 for the expanded hotel that is adjacent to the City of Kingsport Convention Center.  There has been some confusing statements made in the Kingsport Times-News articles below.

There are conflicting statements as how much Meadowview has brought to the area. The Times-News editorial below states property values have increase to $83 million and the August 18 Times-News article below states two different property values ($60 million to over $80 million) and also two different property tax numbers ($1.16 million and $650,000).

Linking the MeadowView Hotel and the Convention Center with other building investments in the MeadowView area is wrong.  It is more of a case that the land was available to build on and developers took advantage of that.

When I visit my doctor in the Meadowview area, I do not stay at the MeadowView Resort and Convention Center at prices that start at $159.00 per night.  In addition, if I wanted to go to Eastman Credit Union, get my hearing checked, get a cup of coffee, get my teeth worked on, have plastic surgery, go to the Social Security office, etc., I don’t have a need for the MeadowView Resort and Convention Center.

It is apparent that the city leaders are attempting to ride on the coattails of the surrounding businesses to justify the MeadowView Convention Center Expansion.

I am sure that the surrounding businesses do not need to ride on the coattails of MeadowView Resort and Convention Center.  They would do just fine if there were no MeadowView Resort and Convention Center.

Meadowview Conference Center does not make money and the taxpayers are the ones that are keeping it afloat. $1.3 million is what is needed each year from the taxpayers to keep it operational and it is very clear that the City of Kingsport is not capable of managing the convention center to make a profit. It would be in the best interest of the taxpayers to give the convention center to private enterprise or to tear it down.

The city plans to expand the convention center at a cost of around $15 million, which would make the taxpayers investment in Meadowview about $41 million   This $41 million includes the golf course, current convention center and the new expanded convention center.

Kingsport Times-News Editorial – August 17, 2009

Three years before MeadowView opened its doors in 1996, appraised property values in the MeadowView Gateway area were $2.7 million. By last year, property values had increased more than thirty-fold to $83 million.

Renovated, expanded MeadowView Marriott marks grand opening – August 18, 2009

it has generated more than $60 million in new private-sector investments in that portion of town. Those investments in turn have generated more than $1.16 million in new property taxes each year.

….This is truly a partnership,” said Mayor Dennis Phillips. “It’s a win-win for the city.”

He said before MeadowView was built, the property was assessed at $2.5 million. Today, the value has jumped to more than $80 million.

“That’s an additional $650,000 a year to city coffers,” Phillips said. “This community owes you (MeadowView) a great debt of gratitude.”

See the following link for more information on MeadowView

Update: Against Building Taxpayer Funded Denominational Medical School in East TN

July 16th, 2009 No comments

King College, a denominational college located in Bristol, Tennessee, has been in discussions with Kingsport, Bristol, and Sullivan County officials to build a medical school in Kingsport and Bristol.

The cost for the medical school would be about $150 million.  King is looking for $50 million to come from the cities of Kingsport ($40 million) and Bristol ($10 million), $50 million from the State of Tennessee, and the remaining $50 million from private donations.

At the July 7, 2009, Kingsport, Tennessee Board of Mayor and Alderman, a resolution was passed on first reading to endorse the King College Medical School Initiative, and pledged its commitment to work with Bristol, Sullivan County, and King College to advance the project.

While it does sound like a good project for the area, there will be a major impact on the taxpayers if this is funded via a property tax increase.

Mayor Dennis Phillips has stated that if Kingsport were to fund $40 million for the project, property taxes would have to be raised 25 cents.

Below are tax rates that have been extracted from the Tennessee Property Tax Rates that show the top 20 cities that have the highest tax rates in Tennessee from 406 different tax rates for the different cities and counties.

I have added 25 cents to the tax rates for the two Kingsport line items (Kingsport-Sullivan and Kingsport-Hawkins) in the table below.  Kingsport, with the 25 cents added, would have a rank of 10 and 12 as having the most expensive tax rates in the state.  Bristol has a rank of 14 and I have no knowledge if they would increase property taxes.

Top 20 Cities with the most expensive property tax rates
R
a
n
k
CountyCityTotal County and City TaxProperty Tax for $150k HomeHousehold Median Income% Taxes from Household IncomeMedian Home Value
1SHELBY MEMPHIS $7.29$2,734$32,2858.47%$130,695
2SHELBY GERMANTOWN $5.63$2,111$113,7331.86%$278,800
3SHELBY BARTLETT $5.63$2,111$74,0912.85%$164,600
4KNOX KNOXVILLE $5.50$2,063$32,5386.34%$102,300
5ANDERSON OAK RIDGE $5.45$2,044$45,4744.49%$120,100
6SHELBY COLLIERVILLE $5.37$2,014$99,2392.03%$255,400
7HAMILTON CHATTANOOGA $5.36$2,009$35,9135.59%$121,100
8SHELBY MILLINGTON $5.32$1,995$43,7534.56%$124,144
9MADISON HUMBOLDT $5.30$1,988$50,0073.98%$181,800
10HAWKINS KINGSPORT $5.11*$1,916$34,3915.57%$99,900
11SHELBY ARLINGTON $5.09$1,909$59,1313.23%$233,597
12SULLIVAN KINGSPORT $5.08*$1,905$34,3915.54%$99,900
13ROANE OAK RIDGE $5.04$1,890$45,4744.16%$120,100
14SULLIVAN BRISTOL $5.03$1,886$36,4545.17%$94,000
15MORGAN OAKDALE $4.98$1,868$32,1745.81%$47,502
16COFFEE MANCHESTER $4.96$1,860$36,6745.07%$112,275
17HAMILTON LOOKOUT MOUNTAIN $4.95$1,858$117,7671.58%$515,354
18HAMILTON RIDGESIDE $4.95$1,858$103,9951.79%$293,387
19LAUDERDALE HENNING $4.95$1,856$23,4077.93%$65,212
20HAMILTON SIGNAL MOUNTAIN $4.93$1,848$78,1752.36%$283,948

* The current city and county combined tax rate for Kingsport-Sullivan County is $4.86 and Kingsport-Hawkins County is $4.86.  Twenty-five cents has been added to each of the Kingsport tax rates in the above table.


The table below again shows the top 20 cites and the effect on the taxpayers’ Household Median Income.  There appears to be a disconnect with those cities having a high tax rate, lower Household Median Income and the percentage of Household Income needed to pay property taxes.

The household median income for Kingsport is $34,391 and the Kingsport majority of Kingsport property owners would pay over 5.5 percent of household income ($150k home) for property taxes if  the 25 cents is added to the Kingsport tax rate.  The Kingsport rank is 6 and 7 and Bristol comes in at a rank of 8 in the table below for the largest percent of household income needed to pay property taxes.

A taxpayer funded medical school would reduce the already low Kingsport household income and would reduce the standard of living for the majority of Kingsport citizens so the city could reap the benefits of increased revenue to spend on other pet projects.

Top 20 Cities that take the highest percentage of income for property taxes
R
a
n
k
CountyCityTotal County and City TaxProperty Tax for $150k HomeHousehold Median Income% Taxes from Household IncomeMedian Home Value
1SHELBY MEMPHIS $7.29$2,734$32,2858.47%$130,695
2LAUDERDALE HENNING $4.95$1,856$23,4077.93%$65,212
3KNOX KNOXVILLE $5.50$2,063$32,5386.34%$102,300
4MORGAN OAKDALE $4.98$1,868$32,1745.81%$47,502
5HAMILTON CHATTANOOGA $5.36$2,009$35,9135.59%$121,100
6HAWKINS KINGSPORT $5.11*$1,916$34,3915.57%$99,900
7SULLIVAN KINGSPORT $5.08*$1,905$34,3915.54%$99,900
8SULLIVAN BRISTOL $5.03$1,886$36,4545.17%$94,000
9COFFEE MANCHESTER $4.96$1,860$36,6745.07%$112,275
10SHELBY MILLINGTON $5.32$1,995$43,7534.56%$124,144
11ANDERSON OAK RIDGE $5.45$2,044$45,4744.49%$120,100
12ROANE OAK RIDGE $5.04$1,890$45,4744.16%$120,100
13MADISON HUMBOLDT $5.30$1,988$50,0073.98%$181,800
14SHELBY ARLINGTON $5.09$1,909$59,1313.23%$233,597
15SHELBY BARTLETT $5.63$2,111$74,0912.85%$164,600
16HAMILTON SIGNAL MOUNTAIN $4.93$1,848$78,1752.36%$283,948
17SHELBY COLLIERVILLE $5.37$2,014$99,2392.03%$255,400
18SHELBY GERMANTOWN $5.63$2,111$113,7331.86%$278,800
19HAMILTON RIDGESIDE $4.95$1,858$103,9951.79%$293,387
20HAMILTON LOOKOUT MOUNTAIN $4.95$1,858$117,7671.58%$515,354

* The current city and county combined tax rate for Kingsport-Sullivan County is $4.86 and Kingsport-Hawkins County is $4.86.  Twenty-five cents has been added to each of the Kingsport tax rates in the above table.


I have heard some members of the Kingsport BMA express their desire to have a college located in Kingsport.  They should keep in mind that there are very large number of cities that have been successful without having a college and who also have a better standard of living than Kingsport.

College Cities

Household Median Income

Knoxville$32,538
Bristol$36,454
Chattanooga$35,913
Johnson City$35,746
Memphis$35,181

The above cities that have a college appear not to have increased the standard of living and have a low household median income.

Below is the household income distribution for Kingsport and the household median income for Kingsport is $34,391.  In the graph below there are 2,636 people who earn less than $10,000  classifying them as living in poverty.

I challenge the elected officials to venture outside of their social and political groups and try to understand the plight of the majority of wage earners in the Kingsport area.  The medical school would bring jobs, but some of these jobs will be imported jobs and the common folks would not have the background or training for these jobs.  Ask what you can do to raise the standard of living (higher income) for Kingsport citizens without imposing a property tax burden.

I feel that the taxpayers should not be taking the risk of funding a medical school when there already is a state funded one in Johnson City.  The need for doctors in this area is questionable since the population is declining in Sullivan County.  If they area has trouble attracting doctors or keeping doctors, then take a hard look at the reason.

Quality of Life issues are important, but a good Standard of Living for local folks just might make the area prosper by increased spending by the majority of citizens.

The bottom line is that the area needs good paying jobs without the additional burden on the taxpayers.

I need to point out that no funding has been voted on so far, but projects such as this grows legs very fast and then its then to late to react.  The intent of this post is to make you aware of the issues so you can make your views know.  Update:  Many elected officials have expressed their support of this project including Lt. Governor Ron Ramsey who may make it a part of his campaign for governor.  Again, I must point out that I am not against the project but am very concerned about it being funded by taxpayers.

Please contact your elected officials and tell them NO to a taxpayer funded denominational medical school.  Click on the email links below and add your comments in your own email program.

email Kingsport BMA
Mayor Dennis Phillips
Vice Mayor Ben Mallicote
Alderman Larry Munsey
Alderman Jantry Shupe
Alderwoman Valerie Joh
Alderman Ken Marsh, Jr.
Alderman Tom Parham
email Tennessee Legislators for area
Lt. Governor Ron Ramsey
Senator Mike Faulk
Rep. Jason E. Mumpower
Rep. Tony Shipley
Rep. Jon Lundberg
Rep. Dale Ford
email Sullivan County Commissioners
See list for
Commissioners individual emails
or
email Mayor and all Sullivan County Commissioners
email this post to a friend
email Candidates for Tennessee Governor
Mike McWherter
Roy Herron
Ward Cammack
Zack Wamp
Bill Haslam
Ron Ramsey
Kim McMillan
Jim Kyle
אורן יומטוב